In the last few years, there has been a clamoring among certain sections of the media, and with a few of Hong Kong’s overtly political lawmakers, for the Mandatory Provident Fund Schemes Authority (MPFA) to force providers to reduce their fees. For many in the industry, this has been recognised as an ill-disguised attempt to gain self-publicity for the politicians, and to hammer down revenues of MPF providers – usually banks, insurance companies or fund management companies – on the part of the media.
The most popular concept raised – to reduce MPF fees – has been the introduction of portability. In effect, this means the introduction of a facility to allow employees to move their MPF from one provider to another, regardless of the intentions of the employer which had selected the original provider in the first place.
For those with experience of the pensions market in other locations, we are well aware that it is dominated by “advisers” and “consultants” offering guidance to their clients on how to set up, invest and manage their retirement schemes. In these places, very often the schemes have hundreds or many thousands of employees. In Hong Kong, the usual employer has much smaller numbers, which is why the MPF was considered a suitable design, in other words to suit the lower-average size companies which exist here.
And getting this advice is important when looking to change MPF provider. So who pays the adviser? Probably not the MPF product provider – the fees are too low to do so. Would the employer pay? Most unlikely, why would they want to have the extra administration of handling multiple MPFs for different employees? And the employee is equally unlikely; after all, what’s the point of trying to reduce fees by a few points if it costs so much in the first place?
But this avoids the crucial issue of fees on MPF. How could MPF funds reduce fees?
The argument that fees on MPF are too high is flawed in many ways. On the one hand, it is certainly true that fees have some scope to be lowered. On the other hand, they are not too high either.
A simple comparison between MPF and mutual funds demonstrates this. What should be far more important, is to ensure the fund selected for your MPF is capable of achieving consistent returns. Ideally well-above the market average.
In recent years the MPF has become something of a political football, being kicked from one side of the pitch to the other, and often without a referee! This serves no purpose other than to confuse those for whom the MPF is designed to benefit – the employees.
Our website utilises standard technology called "cookies" and web server logs to collect information about how the Hubbis site is used. Cookies are a feature of your web browser software that allows servers to recognise the computer used to access a website. This information is collected on an aggregate basis. None of this information is associated with you as an individual. If you continue to access the Hubbis site, we will assume that you agree to receive cookies. You may choose to disable cookies on your computer, however it is possible that some parts of the Hubbis site may not operate correctly if you do so
The content on this site is the copyright of Hubbis (HK) Limited.
We take all reasonable steps to ensure that the information on this Website is correct. However, we do not guarantee the correctness or completeness of material on this Website. Neither we nor any other party (whether or not involved in producing, maintaining or delivering this Website), shall be liability or responsible for any kind of loss or damage that may result to you or a third party as a result of your or their use of our website.
The information provided is for general information purposes only. It is not, and should not be construed as, financial or other professional advice.
In the material we make available on our site, we rely on a wide variety of sources. We believe these sources of data to be accurate and reliable, but sometimes they may not be. Hubbis.com makes no claims or representations as to the accuracy, completeness, or truth of any material contained on our site. Nor is Hubbis.com liable for any errors or delays in the content or transmission of the data on our site.
© Hubbis (HK) Limited 2015. All Rights Reserved.